Oliver Wendell Holmes is credited with this great quote – “I wouldn’t give a fig for simplicity this side of complexity, but I’d give my right arm for simplicity on the other side of complexity.”
I remember Haddon Robinson using this quote to distinguish two types of simplicity in preaching. This side of complexity the simplicity isn’t worth much. Often very young preachers offer this because it is all they have to give. Listeners will resonate at a certain level, appreciating the simplicity combined with a young preacher getting launched into ministry. But there will also be a lack of depth, of experience, of insight, of nuance, and of genuine impact. This less-than-a-fig’s worth of simple preaching will hopefully yield to a pursuit of something more valuable.
The goal is arms’-worth simplicity. This is the kind of simplicity that great preachers offer. They have a much greater and more personal understanding of the Bible, of life, of their listeners, and of themselves. This kind of preacher knows how to plumb the depths of Scripture and serve up a simple message that is not paper thin and feather light, but life impacting and pregnant with deep truth, resonating with listeners as true. To hear a great preacher preach simply is heart warming, life changing and profoundly satisfying.
But there is a journey from less-than-fig simplicity to arms’-worth simplicity. It is a journey through complexity. Here are five quick thoughts on the journey:
1. It is a necessary journey. It may be tempting to stay this side of complexity and try to fake depth by copying preachers that have made the journey. This cannot be effectively faked. Knowing comments, beard stroking, profound stares and implying you are a deep well simply won’t convince the more mature listeners. Determine to prayerfully make the journey over the next years to that far side of complexity.
2. It is a multi-faceted journey. It is tempting to assume that the journey simply involves learning a lot. It includes that, but also much more. By all means go to seminary, read lots, learn loads, but know that merely filling your head with knowledge will not get you through the dark forest of complexity – it will probably plant you right in the middle! There will also be life experience needed, and only God can orchestrate that. There may well be suffering – sometimes “low level” and sometimes a horrendous “crucible experience.” There will need to be painful feedback pursued and taken to heart. This journey is not easy, neither is it quick:
3. It can be a slow journey. Know that it can take years to successfully get through the forest. Many preachers play around the edges of the forest, but never plunge in and come through to the other side. They read a bit, study a bit (even getting a degree can be just studying a bit), and try to act like the three bushes they have hung out with constitute a forest! It is hard to spot shallowness and ignorance in the mirror, but pray for a clear view of yourself, and pray for honest insight from others.
4. The preacher should determine to make this journey. Only God knows the journey through the forest, but pray for Him to lead you and start taking steps. And remember your goal is simplicity. Know that your listeners won’t love the complexity as much as you do, so always look to grow in simplicity in your preaching, wherever you are in the journey. Often you will fail, but always aim to communicate as clearly as you can.
5. The listeners will need to have patience with the preacher. If you know someone on this journey, then please support them, cheer them on, encourage them. Give them feedback that will help them grow. Give them grace and space to make mistakes and to make progress. Don’t chase them back to cheap simplicity, and don’t chase them out of your church because they are trying to grow. You will be glad when they make it through, and they will make it through, in part, because of your help!